Recognition

Ranked a top carrier by collision repair shops

Acuity is named one of the best insurers in the country for claims service in the 2025 CRASH Network Insurer Report Card. In addition to being the third best insurers nationwide, Acuity is ranked #1 in the Great Lakes Region, #3 in the Plains Region, and #2 in the Rocky Mountains Region. *****

Awards From ACORD

Acuity's, Joan Ravanelli Miller, J.D., Ph.D., General Counsel and Vice President – Human Resources, was honored with the 2022 Women’s Insurance Advancement Award. Last year, Sheri Murphy, Vice President - Services and Administration, was honored with the 2021 Women’s Insurance Advancement Award. Acuity also received two ACORD Case Study Awards for expanding digital distribution in small commercial, an ACORD Implementation Excellence Award for policy download modernization, and Susan Matzat, Systems Architect, was honored with the ACORD Community Leadership Award.

Super Regional Property/Casualty Insurers^TM

Acuity is named to the 2022 list of Super Regional Property-Casualty (P&C) Insurers. We are ranked #8 out of 147.

Deloitte Wisconsin 75

Acuity is named to the Deloitte Wisconsin 75, the annual program honoring the state's largest closely held firms for their impact on Wisconsin's economy. 2023 is Acuity’s 17th year on the list, and we are ranked #21.

Ward’s 50

We have been named to the Ward’s 50 for 24 consecutive years.

Five-Star Carrier

Acuity was named a Five-Star Carrier by Insurance Business America.

Creative excellence

Acuity has earned multiple awards for creative excellence from the ICMA, Hermes Creative Awards, MarCom, and more.

Agent accolades

In recent years we have earned Company of the Year awards from independent insurance agent associations in multiple states, including New Mexico, Indiana, and Minnesota.